New York Jets running back Breece Hall recently made headlines when he appeared to criticize offensive line coach Keith Carter on social media. The controversy began when former Tennessee Titans offensive tackle Taylor Lewan posted a message on Instagram praising his former head coach Mike Vrabel, but also took a subtle jab at Carter, who was previously on Vrabel’s staff in Tennessee
In his post, Lewan said he “loved” Vrabel as a coach, “except 2018,” and also “loved his coaching staff (besides Keith Carter).” Hall responded to Lewan’s post with five laughing emojis, seemingly endorsing Lewan’s criticism of Carter[1][2]. Mekhi Becton, the Jets’ offensive tackle, also engaged with Lewan’s post, hinting at his alignment with Lewan’s sentiments towards Carter’s coaching methods[2].
The criticism of Carter comes after a challenging season for the Jets’ offensive line, which struggled with injuries and inconsistent play. As a result, the Jets’ rushing attack was not as effective as many had hoped, with Hall finishing just shy of 1,000 yards rushing despite a strong rookie campaign[1].
Carter, who joined the Jets this season after a stint with the Titans, has faced scrutiny for his coaching style. Some players have reportedly chafed at his aggressive approach, with sources saying he unfairly called out players, particularly Becton[4]. Former Falcons fullback Patrick DiMarco, who played under Carter in Atlanta, also weighed in on Lewan’s post, saying “Keith Carter was nobody’s favorite coach and I can say that with a lot of confidence.”[4]
Despite the criticism, Jets head coach Robert Saleh has expressed confidence in Carter’s abilities and does not anticipate any major changes to the coaching staff this offseason[1][4]. Carter himself acknowledged that he needs to deliver his message differently, saying “I’m focusing on making sure my timing is right and I do it the right way.”[4]
The Jets have made some moves to bolster their offensive line this offseason, signing veterans Tyron Smith, Morgan Moses, and John Simpson[4]. However, the relationship between Carter and his players, particularly Hall and Becton, will be something to watch as the team prepares for the 2024 season.
It’s worth noting that the Jets have retained Carter as their offensive line coach, despite the criticism from players[5]. This suggests that the team still believes in his abilities and is willing to give him another opportunity to prove himself.
In conclusion, the criticism of Jets offensive line coach Keith Carter by running back Breece Hall and others has shone a spotlight on the dynamics between coaches and players in the NFL. While Carter has faced challenges in his first season with the Jets, the team appears to be standing by him as they look to improve their offensive line and rushing attack in 2024. The relationship between Carter and his players, particularly Hall and Becton, will be a key storyline to follow as the season approaches.