The New York Knicks are looking to improve upon last season’s playoff performance, but a slow start to the preseason has prompted conversations about adjustments, particularly around the role of versatile guard-forward Josh Hart. After scoring just 2 points across several preseason outings, Hart has openly suggested that a shift in his role could benefit both himself and the team as they head into the regular season.
While Hart’s contributions often extend beyond scoring—he’s known for his rebounding, defense, and hustle—his recent struggles have led him to consider how best he can serve the team. In a league where adaptability is key, Hart’s willingness to embrace a new role speaks to his team-first mentality and the larger dynamics at play within the Knicks’ roster as they aim for a successful season.
Since joining the Knicks, Josh Hart has been valued for his energy and versatility. Last season, his ability to play multiple positions, defend different types of players, and provide a spark off the bench made him a crucial part of the Knicks’ rotation. His contributions were especially vital during the playoff run, where his gritty style of play helped the Knicks overcome tough opponents and make a deeper push into the postseason.
However, the 2023-24 preseason has posed new challenges for Hart. Despite playing significant minutes, he has struggled to find his rhythm on offense, managing to score just 2 points in a stretch that has been defined by missed shots and limited scoring opportunities. For a player who prides himself on making an impact wherever he is needed, this lack of offensive production has been a cause for concern, both for Hart and the Knicks’ coaching staff.
Hart’s struggles have been met with a mix of understanding and urgency. Head coach Tom Thibodeau, known for his emphasis on defensive intensity and disciplined play, has highlighted the importance of each player finding their role within the team’s structure. For Hart, this has meant focusing on other aspects of his game like rebounding and defending, but he has now proposed that a shift in his role could help unlock more of his offensive potential.
Following the preseason performances, Josh Hart addressed the media and hinted at his willingness to adapt, suggesting that a change in his role might benefit both him and the team. “I think it’s just about finding where I can be most effective,” Hart said. “If that means playing a different role or approaching things a little differently, I’m all for it. My goal is to help this team win, and I’m willing to do whatever it takes to make that happen.”
Hart’s suggestion has sparked discussions among analysts and fans about what a potential role change might look like. Some believe that he could be utilized more as a secondary ball-handler or playmaker in the second unit, allowing him to facilitate offense and create opportunities for others. This would take advantage of Hart’s underrated passing ability and could give the Knicks a different dynamic when the starters are off the floor.
Others speculate that Hart might be more effective playing closer to the basket, where his rebounding prowess could be combined with scoring opportunities off cuts and put-backs. Given the Knicks’ focus on improving their spacing and shooting around star guard Jalen Brunson, there is also a possibility that Hart’s role could evolve to include more catch-and-shoot opportunities, aiming to boost his scoring output.
One of the key factors in Hart’s role adjustment is balancing his defensive contributions with a more consistent offensive presence. Throughout his career, Hart has built a reputation as a tenacious defender who can guard multiple positions, and this defensive versatility is something the Knicks value highly. However, as the team looks to improve their scoring output, particularly from their bench unit, there is a need for more offensive contributions from players like Hart.
Hart’s suggestion for a role change comes at a time when the Knicks are experimenting with different lineups and rotations in the preseason. The team has been exploring combinations that can provide more scoring depth, especially against Eastern Conference contenders like the Milwaukee Bucks and Boston Celtics, who have bolstered their rosters with star power.
If Hart can find a way to contribute more on the offensive end without sacrificing his defensive intensity, it could be a game-changer for the Knicks. His ability to adapt and fill different roles would give Thibodeau more flexibility in managing rotations and adjusting to matchups throughout the season. It would also alleviate some of the scoring burden on key players like Brunson, Julius Randle, and RJ Barrett.
The Knicks are entering the new season with high hopes, aiming to build on their previous playoff appearance and position themselves as a top contender in the Eastern Conference. With the addition of new players and the continued development of young talent, the team is looking to strike a balance between maintaining their defensive identity and adding more offensive firepower.
Josh Hart’s suggestion of a role change is a reflection of the adjustments that the team is willing to consider as they refine their strategy. For Hart, this could mean embracing a new set of responsibilities, whether it involves taking on more playmaking duties, focusing on attacking the rim, or finding his shooting touch from beyond the arc.
As the regular season approaches, all eyes will be on how the Knicks integrate these changes and whether Hart’s role can evolve to maximize his impact on the floor. His willingness to adapt and put the team’s success first is a positive sign for a Knicks squad that is eager to take the next step in their journey.
With the Eastern Conference growing more competitive, the ability of players like Josh Hart to adapt and find new ways to contribute will be critical to the Knicks’ success. And while his preseason struggles have raised questions, Hart’s proactive approach suggests that he is ready to meet the challenge head-on, aiming to be a difference-maker as the season unfolds. For the Knicks, the hope is that these adjustments will lead to more wins and a deeper run come playoff time.