As the Texas Longhorns continue their push toward a College Football Playoff berth, the conversation around their quarterback situation is heating up. Quinn Ewers, the team’s starting quarterback, has been a key figure in Texas’ resurgence this season, but lingering injury concerns have sparked calls for freshman phenom Arch Manning to step into the spotlight.
Ewers, who has dealt with injuries throughout his collegiate career, including a shoulder issue earlier this season, remains the clear leader of the Longhorns’ offense when healthy. However, his physical limitations have led to growing debates among fans and analysts about whether it’s time to give Manning, the highly touted five-star recruit and member of the Manning football dynasty, an opportunity to take the reins.
Ewers sustained a shoulder injury against Houston earlier in the season, which sidelined him for several weeks. While he has since returned to action, there have been questions about whether he is fully recovered. His performances since returning have been solid but not spectacular, leading some to wonder if he’s operating at less than 100%.
In Texas’ recent game against Iowa State, Ewers was seen favoring his shoulder after a hard hit in the second quarter. Although he stayed in the game, the incident reignited concerns about his durability. With the stakes higher than ever, the Longhorns need a quarterback capable of leading them through the grind of postseason play.
Arch Manning arrived at Texas with sky-high expectations as the No. 1 overall recruit in the 2023 class. The nephew of Peyton and Eli Manning, Arch has football royalty coursing through his veins, and his decision to join the Longhorns was seen as a landmark moment for the program.
Although Manning has yet to take significant snaps in live game action, his performances in practice and scrimmages have drawn rave reviews. Head coach Steve Sarkisian has praised Manning’s poise, work ethic, and ability to quickly grasp the complexities of the offense.
Fans clamoring for Manning to replace Ewers believe the young quarterback’s combination of talent and pedigree makes him the perfect option to lead Texas in the event that Ewers’ health becomes a liability. His arm strength, accuracy, and mobility offer an exciting dimension to the Longhorns’ offense, and many feel it’s only a matter of time before he assumes the starting role.
Despite the calls for Manning to take over, Sarkisian has been steadfast in his support for Ewers. The third-year head coach has repeatedly emphasized Ewers’ leadership and experience as invaluable assets to the team.
“Quinn is our guy,” Sarkisian said in a recent press conference. “He’s battled through injuries before, and he’s shown that he’s capable of leading this team. Arch is a fantastic talent, and his time will come, but right now, we’re focused on Quinn and the job he’s doing for us.”
This loyalty to Ewers is understandable, given his role in leading Texas to a 10-1 record and a spot in the Big 12 Championship. Ewers has thrown for over 2,800 yards and 20 touchdowns this season, showcasing his ability to make plays when the team needs them most.
While the debate over Ewers and Manning is compelling, the Longhorns’ ultimate goal is clear: secure a playoff spot and contend for a national championship. Whether that means continuing to rely on Ewers or making the bold decision to insert Manning into the lineup will depend on Ewers’ health and performance in the coming weeks.
The Longhorns face a pivotal stretch, including the Big 12 Championship and a potential playoff berth. If Ewers’ injuries worsen or his play falters, the calls for Manning could grow louder. For now, Texas fans can only trust Sarkisian to make the decision that gives the Longhorns the best chance to win.
The quarterback debate in Austin reflects the high stakes and expectations surrounding the Texas program. Ewers has earned the right to lead the team, but Manning’s presence looms large as a potential game-changer. With Texas on the brink of its first playoff appearance, every decision will be magnified. Whether it’s Ewers or Manning under center, one thing is certain: the Longhorns’ championship hopes rest heavily on the quarterback position.