Free Agent Quarterbacks Seahawks Could Consider as a Geno Smith Replacement
As the Seattle Seahawks contemplate their future under center, questions about Geno Smith’s long-term viability as their starting quarterback loom large. Smith’s performance has been respectable, but Seattle’s ambitions for a deeper playoff push may require fresh leadership at quarterback. With the free-agent market offering intriguing options, the Seahawks have the opportunity to reset their quarterback position with a proven veteran or a younger talent. Here are four free-agent quarterbacks Seattle could consider as potential replacements for Smith.
1. Derek Carr
Derek Carr’s unexpected release by the Las Vegas Raiders during the 2023 offseason left many surprised, given his proven track record as a starting quarterback. Carr, a four-time Pro Bowl selection, is a highly experienced passer with a reputation for making clutch plays.
Why He Fits Seattle
Carr’s arm strength and accuracy would align well with Seattle’s offensive scheme, which emphasizes explosive plays downfield. The Seahawks boast a talented receiving corps, including DK Metcalf and Tyler Lockett, and Carr has the experience to maximize their potential. Additionally, Carr’s leadership could help stabilize Seattle’s locker room and provide consistency at the quarterback position.
Potential Challenges
Carr may demand a high salary, which could strain Seattle’s salary cap. Moreover, his performance under pressure has been inconsistent at times, raising concerns about his ability to deliver in critical moments.
2. Jacoby Brissett
Jacoby Brissett has earned a reputation as one of the NFL’s most reliable backup quarterbacks, but he’s shown flashes of starting potential in stints with the Indianapolis Colts, Miami Dolphins, and Cleveland Browns.
Why He Fits Seattle
Brissett is a steady, low-risk option who excels at managing games and minimizing turnovers. His ability to play within the system and adapt to various offensive schemes makes him an attractive candidate for the Seahawks, who could use his efficiency and decision-making skills.
Brissett’s mobility is another asset, as Seattle’s offensive line occasionally struggles to provide consistent pass protection. He has the ability to extend plays with his legs, which could prove valuable in a Seahawks offense that thrives on creativity.
Potential Challenges
While Brissett is dependable, he lacks the dynamic playmaking ability of top-tier quarterbacks. If Seattle aims to compete with high-powered offenses in the NFC, Brissett might not provide the explosive production needed to keep up.
Jimmy Garoppolo, formerly of the San Francisco 49ers and Las Vegas Raiders, has proven himself as a capable starter when healthy. Despite injury concerns, his resume includes multiple deep playoff runs and a Super Bowl appearance
Garoppolo’s experience in hi-pressure situations would be invaluable for a Seahawks team aiming to return to championship contention. He thrives in quick-read, play-action-heavy systems, which align well with Seattle’s offensive approach.
Garoppolo’s familiarity with NFC West defenses could also provide Seattle with an edge in divisional matchups. His ability to distribute the ball effectively to playmakers would complement the Seahawks’ offensive weapons.
**Potential Challenges**
Garoppolo’s injury history is a major red flag. Seattle would need to invest in a strong backup plan to mitigate the risk of another extended absence. Additionally, his limited ability to stretch the field vertically may not fully utilize Seattle’s deep-ball threats.
4. Baker Mayfield
Baker Mayfield’s career has been a rollercoaster of highs and lows, but his 2023 resurgence with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers showed glimpses of the player who was once a first-overall draft pick.Why He Fits Seattle
Mayfield’s competitive edge and playmaking ability could inject energy into the Seahawks’ offense. Known for his mobility and improvisational skills, Mayfield could thrive behind an offensive line that is still developing. His ability to extend plays and take risks could spark big moments for Seattle’s offense.
Mayfield’s chip-on-his-shoulder mentality aligns well with the Seahawks’ gritty identity. He has a knack for rallying teams and overcoming adversity, which could resonate in Seattle’s culture.Potential Challenges
Mayfield’s inconsistency remains a concern, as he’s prone to turnover-heavy stretches. While his confidence can be an asset, it can also lead to forcing plays that result in costly mistakes. The Seahawks would need to weigh his upside against the risk of erratic performances.
Replacing Geno Smith is no small decision, as stability at quarterback is critical for sustained success. Each of the aforementioned quarterbacks offers a unique skill set and potential to elevate Seattle’s offense.
Derek Carrprovides experience and leadership but comes with a hefty price tag.
Jacoby Brissett offers reliability and efficiency, though he may lack game-changing ability.
Jimmy Garoppolobrings playoff pedigree but carries significant injury concerns.
Baker Mayfield delivers passion and explosiveness but needs to prove he can be consistently effective.
Ultimately, the Seahawks’ choice will depend on their priorities: whether they value a proven veteran with playoff experience, a cost-effective game manager, or a high-upside gamble. With a strong roster and a competitive division, the Seahawks have the pieces in place to make a deep postseason run — provided they find the right leader to guide them.