The Georgia Bulldogs are entering the 2025 season with high expectations, but uncertainty remains at the quarterback position. Following Kirby Smart’s announcement of a major concern emerging from spring practices, national analysts have weighed in on what this means for Gunner Stockton, one of Georgia’s most intriguing quarterbacks.
Stockton, a former four-star recruit out of Tiger, Georgia, has been patiently waiting for his opportunity to take over the reins of Georgia’s offense. With Carson Beck declaring for the NFL Draft after leading the Bulldogs to another dominant season, many expected Stockton to be next in line. However, Smart’s recent comments have raised new questions about the pecking order under center, and analysts believe Stockton’s fate at Georgia is becoming clearer.
Kirby Smart’s Spring Concern: Quarterback Development in the Spotlight
During a recent press conference, Kirby Smart addressed the state of Georgia’s quarterback room, noting that while there is talent, there remains significant work to be done. Smart’s main concern appears to be the lack of separation between the contenders, hinting that the battle to replace Beck may be more open-ended than initially expected.
“We have a lot of talent in that room, but there’s still a long way to go,” Smart said. “It’s about leadership, consistency, and understanding the system at a high level. Right now, we’re still working through that.”
These comments have sparked speculation that Stockton may not be the outright favorite for the job, despite being in the system for multiple seasons. Instead, Brock Vandagriff’s transfer departure to Kentucky and the arrival of five-star freshman Ryan Puglisi have intensified competition in Athens.
National Analysts: Gunner Stockton’s Time is Now—or Never
Following Smart’s remarks, several national analysts have weighed in on what this means for Gunner Stockton. According to ESPN’s Greg McElroy, Stockton has been presented with an opportunity, but he must seize control of the job sooner rather than later.
“This is Gunner Stockton’s chance to prove he’s the guy,” McElroy said. “He’s been patient, he’s learned the system, and now it’s about execution. But if the door stays open too long, a guy like Puglisi or even a transfer could come in and take that spot.”
Fox Sports’ Joel Klatt echoed similar sentiments, adding that Georgia’s offensive scheme is built to favor experienced quarterbacks who can manage games efficiently rather than relying on raw athleticism.
“Smart and [offensive coordinator Mike] Bobo want a guy who can keep the offense moving, make smart decisions, and protect the football,” Klatt explained. “Stockton has the tools, but if he doesn’t take command in the spring, Georgia may be forced to look elsewhere.”
With Puglisi pushing hard and potential transfer options still available after spring, Stockton’s fate at Georgia could be at a crossroads.
Stockton’s Strengths: Why He Still Has a Shot
While there is growing doubt, there are also plenty of reasons why Stockton should not be counted out just yet.
1. System Familiarity
Stockton has been in Georgia’s system for multiple years, giving him an inherent advantage over younger players. He understands Bobo’s playbook, knows the speed of SEC defenses, and has built chemistry with Georgia’s weapons.
2. Dual-Threat Ability
Unlike Beck, Stockton brings a dual-threat element to the table, allowing Georgia to incorporate more designed runs and RPO (Run-Pass Option) packages. This could be a game-changer if Georgia wants to evolve offensively.
3. Leadership & Patience
Stockton’s willingness to wait for his opportunity instead of transferring demonstrates his commitment to Georgia’s program. This type of loyalty and team-first mentality is something Smart values deeply.
However, these strengths alone may not be enough if Stockton does not outperform his competition in the next few months.
The Puglisi Factor: Georgia’s Future May Be Sooner Than Expected
One of the biggest wild cards in this situation is Ryan Puglisi, the five-star freshman who has already impressed coaches in early workouts.
Puglisi, who was part of Georgia’s 2024 recruiting class, was seen as more of a developmental prospect compared to Dylan Raiola, who ultimately flipped to Nebraska. However, recent reports suggest Puglisi is further along in his development than expected, and that he could push for playing time sooner rather than later.
If Puglisi continues to shine, it could force Georgia into a difficult decision:
- Do they stick with Stockton, who has waited his turn but has yet to prove himself in games?
- Or do they accelerate Puglisi’s timeline, handing the offense to a young but ultra-talented quarterback?
According to Rivals recruiting analyst Adam Gorney, Georgia is keeping all options open, including the transfer portal if neither quarterback locks down the starting job.
“Georgia is going to do whatever it takes to win another national championship,” Gorney said. “If that means bringing in another transfer, they won’t hesitate.”
What’s Next for Stockton and Georgia?
Stockton still has time to prove himself, but he needs to take control of the job before spring ends.
If he struggles or fails to separate himself, the Bulldogs may enter the summer with a wide-open QB battle, increasing the chances of either Puglisi leapfrogging him or Georgia pursuing a transfer quarterback.
For now, Stockton’s fate remains in his own hands. However, the pressure has never been higher, and his window of opportunity is shrinking.
Will Gunner Stockton rise to the occasion and cement himself as the next great Georgia quarterback? Or will Kirby Smart and the Bulldogs look in another direction?
Spring practices may determine his destiny in Athens—and potentially the future of Georgia football.
WR Brady Marchese has committed to Georgia,